C.I.A. in contempt

By Larry Neumeister
NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge declined to find the CIA in contempt for destroying videotapes of Sept. 11 detainee interrogations, saying to do so would serve no beneficial purpose and the CIA had put in place new procedures to prevent such destruction from happening again.U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein said in a written ruling that the CIA has since remedied its failure to produce videotapes in response to requests by the American Civil Liberties Union. He wrote that the people processing the ACLU’s Freedom of Information Act request may not have been aware of the videotapes’ existence before they were destroyed.The government has acknowledged destroying 92 videotapes, including those containing interrogations of a high-level al-Qaida lieutenant who claimed he suffered physical and mental torture at the hands of the CIA. The tapes were destroyed in 2005.The judge said a contempt finding would be impractical and told the CIA to investigate itself and report how it will prevent employees from destroying information in the future. He noted that the CIA adopted two new policies regarding document preservation to ensure that destruction of any documents outside of routine management of CIA materials will not occur without a review by lawyers to ensure they are preserved for legal proceedings or congressional oversight activity.

The judge said the CIA’s new protocols would have “a remedial and deterrent effect should a CIA official think to destroy documents.””The protocols should lead to better communication and more complete written records within the agency and across the government when an issue of document destruction or retention arises within the agency,” he said. “The CIA’s new protocols should lead to greater accountability within the agency and prevent another episode like the videotapes’ destruction.”Alexander Abdo, staff attorney with the ACLU National Security Project, wrote the ACLU was “profoundly disappointed by the court’s unwillingness to label as contempt what it describes as the CIA’s ‘dereliction.'”

“We also strongly disagree with the court’s finding that the CIA has ‘remedied’ the destruction,” Abdo wrote. “The truth is that the CIA destroyed evidence of torture, and the destruction of this evidence has made it harder to hold high-level officials accountable for the abuse that they authorized.”

Carly Sullivan, a spokeswoman for federal lawyers who argued the case, said the government had no comment on the ruling.

In his ruling, the judge noted that the ACLU had cited a recently published article by a former general counsel for the CIA that accused the CIA’s former deputy director of operations of defying orders and going behind the top CIA lawyer’s back to destroy the videotapes.

He said the argument premised on the belief that one high-ranking official defied orders and destroyed the tapes undermines the ACLU’s contention that the CIA as an agency should be held in contempt for the conduct.

Still, the judge wrote, “the lapses of individuals cannot excuse the failures of the agency.” He said the CIA had an obligation to identify or produce the videotapes and “cannot be excused in its dereliction because of particular individuals’ lapses.”

The administration of President George W. Bush had said some tapes were destroyed to protect the identities of the government questioners while the Department of Justice was debating whether the interrogation tactics were legal.

In September 2009, the judge cited national security concerns in ruling that the CIA did not have to release hundreds of documents related to the destruction of the videotapes. He has said he likely would have ruled against public disclosure of videotapes documenting new harsh questioning techniques if the CIA had not destroyed them.

An ACLU lawsuit already has forced the release of legal memos authorizing harsh interrogation methods, including waterboarding, a type of simulated drowning, and slamming suspects into walls, techniques described by critics as torture.
.
We can no longer in good conscience trust the criminals to police themselves. Link to this article from forums and blogs. Mention it with links in your comments on blogs. PROMOTE IT.
 .
PLEASE SHARE- Re-Post to Reddit, Digg, Facebook, Twitter, etc. (below)
.
.
Related articles:
.
President Obama is blocking the release of RECENT detainee abuse photos WARNING These are actually pictures of TORTURE
.
30 Kinds of (approved) TORTURE currently being used by the C.I.A.
.
UPDATED: The Obama administration is holding 27,000 kidnapped people in secret prisons
More Torture Pics: Torture by U.S. continues under Obama administration
TORTURE Continues: Obama Administration Uses Navy Ships, Not Secret Prisons, For Interrogations
.
C.I.A. TORTURES CHILDREN
.
President Obama is blocking the release of even more TORTURE pics- Torture by U.S. continues under Obama
.
Psyops: Kept awake for four days by loud music
.
Former Interrogator Rebukes Cheney for Torture Speech
.
.
CIA tortured German man
.
.
Physicians for Human Rights Report: Doctors had ‘central role’ in CIA abuse and human experimentation
.
Congress, the CIA and Pres. Obama have LIED to us about Torture And Secret Prisons
.
Senators: CIA withholding secret interrogation review
.
.
New report: Gitmo costs U.S. $2.7 million per prisoner
.
Strike Updates: Hunger Strike: Guantanamo force-feedings
.
Guantanamo Bay prison: 155 inmates still being Tortured but NO charges
.
Why I keep working to close Guantánamo
http://generalstrikeusa.wordpress.com/2014/01/17/obama-kidnapped-tortured-sorry-not/

.
.
Obamas Executive Assassination Wing
.
Soldier admits Afghan massacre
.
Iraq war vet’s suicide letter alleges ‘war crimes,’ abandonment
.
Marine demoted for urinating on corpses
.
CIA finally admits it was behind 1953 Iran coup
.
(A Congressional report reveals) The C.I.A is a criminal Enterprise
.
C.I.A.s Real Role in the Afghan Heroin Trade
.
C.I.A & the MAFIA & the Global Drug Trade (Then & Now)
.
Syrian Revolution or CIA coup?
.
The Obama governments “State Secrets”
.
.
IRS scandal: Right-wing fear of government isn’t paranoid
.
U.S. government & DHS are compiling dossiers on “anti-government activists”
.
Obama’s FBI Pick No Friend of the Constitution
.
Obama Defends Right to Take All Your Phone Records
.
.
Verizon is turning your phone records over to the government
.
.
U.S. intelligence mining data from nine U.S. Internet companies in broad secret program
.
How Google and Facebook Cooperated with the NSA and PRISM
.
.
.
The Supreme Court Decided Your Silence Can Be Used Against You
.
.
Warrantless Surveillance: Project SHAMROCK
.
U.S. government to fight for warrantless GPS tracking
.
Know Your Rights: CISPA Passes
.
Know Your Rights: FISA passes
.
CISPA and the NSA’s Ability to Read Your Emails
.
Why We’re Suing the NSA
.
Uncompromising Photos Expose Juvenile Detention in America
.
Suit claims abuse, filth at juvenile detention center
.
The Crisis of Juvenile Prison Rape: A New Report: “Sexual abuse in juvenile detention is a national crisis”
.
.
Pennsylvania Judge Sentenced For 28 Years For Selling Kids to the Prison System
.
Cops Go Undercover at High School to Bust Special-Needs Kid for Pot: Why Are Police So Desperate to Throw Kids in Jail?
.
Man alleging police torture released from prison
.
18 LA sheriff’s deputies charged in corruption, inmate abuse
.
Texas Student Fatally Shot by Campus Police After Traffic Stop
.
30 Cases of Extreme Police Brutality and Blatant Misconduct
.
Police under scrutiny
.
Top 1,000 Cases of police brutality in the United States
.
Know Your Rights With Police Officers
.
Know Your Rights- Detention And Pat Down- Do’s and Don’ts
.
Know Your Rights: Supreme Court Ruling Allows Strip Searches for Any Arrest
.
.
.
(How to) Detecting Police Personnel/Vehicles
.
Know Your Rights: Obama’s War On Weed
.
10 Ways to Spot an Informant
.
DRUG BUST: Five Tips for Spotting an Undercover Cop
.
“A Living Death,” Cruel and unusual Punishment: Life imprisonment without parole for minor drug charges http://generalstrikeusa.wordpress.com/2013/12/03/a-living-death-cruel-and-unusual-punishment-life-imprisonment-without-parole-for-minor-drug-charges/
.
.
FBI Successfully Foils Another FBI Plot
FBI says the Government Is Spying on Americans with Drones, Too
.
Strike Updates: FBI warns of U.S. government breaches by Anonymous hackers
.
FBI Ties Chicago Representatives to Zimbabwe Lobbying
.
The FBI is in your TV watching you…
.
FBI can remotely activate microphones in Android smartphones
.
FBI Raid News Media Offices
.
FBI agent apologizes to victims- The F.B.I. and MAFIA gang boss James “Whitey” Bulger Pt. 3
.
F.B.I. Counterterrorism Agents Monitored Occupy Movement, Records Show
.
FBI Agents Dating Drug Dealers, Paying for Sex
.
The F.B.I. and Dr. King
.
FBI removes many redactions in Marilyn Monroe file
.
.
Money Laundering: Follow the Hedge Funds
 .
Banks Financing Mexican Drug Cartels Admits Wells Fargo
 .
HSBC banks actively laundered money for drug lords and terrorist
 .
Are you willing to be arrested?
.
237 Millionaires in Congress
.
Wealth Gap Between Congress and Average Americans Widens
.
Traitors (How Congress Profits from Never ending War)
.
One corrupt party or the other
.
Police Kill Innocent People in the “War on Drugs” 10 Shocking Examples
.
Philadelphia Closes 23 Schools, New $400 Million Prison Being Built
.
Lessons From Thoreau: Reflection, Integrity, Civil Disobedience
.
Make the Rich Even Richer Pt. 4 The System is RIGGED
.
The SYSTEM is NOT broke, its RIGGED Pt. 3 Can You Trust the President, Congress or the Courts to Protect You
.
The SYSTEM is NOT broke Pt 2 Everything Is Rigged: The Biggest Price-Fixing Scandal Ever
.
.

5 comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s