By Daniel Kelley
GORDONVILLE, Pennsylvania (Reuters) – The debate over U.S. healthcare reform that has gripped the nation and led to a government shutdown is of small concern in rural Pennsylvania’s Amish country for a very simple reason.
Along with eschewing cars and many other modern technologies, the descendants of 18th-Century German immigrants who practice the Amish and Old Order Mennonite religions, have effectively opted out of Obamacare, along with most federal safety net programs.
A little-known provision of the law with its roots in a 1950s battle over Social Security exempts these communities from the individual mandate, an element of the Affordable Care Act that requires most Americans to purchase health insurance in some form.
But it is not the idea of health insurance the Amish reject – the close-knit communities essentially insure themselves.
“We have our own health care,” said a retired Amish carpenter, who like other Amish interviewed for this story, asked that his name not be used because of a traditional aversion to publicity and bringing attention to oneself.
“They (hospitals) give you a bill,” he said. “If you can’t pay it, your church will.”
The Amish system is a little more complicated than that. Some 280,000 people live in Amish communities scattered through the United States, with the largest populations in Pennsylvania, Ohio and Indiana, according to research by Elizabethtown College in Pennsylvania.
While practices vary by community, most Amish fund their health care through a system that merges church aid, benefit auctions and negotiated discounts with local hospitals – promising quick cash payment in exchange for lower rates.
“The way they come together to pay for health care is amazing,” said Jan Bergen, chief operating officer at Lancaster General Health. “It’s a tithing. Their sense of responsibility extends beyond themselves and to the community.”
The Amish exemption to Obamacare dates back nearly 60 years to when Congress extended the Social Security tax to the self-employed and to farmers. Many Amish refused to pay. The Internal Revenue Service moved to enforce the law, sometimes with disastrous public relations consequences.
“There was an Amish guy who refused to pay Social Security. IRS agents confiscated his horses while he was out in the field plowing,” said Donald Kraybill, author of “The Amish” and professor at Elizabethtown College.
In 1965, Congress passed a law giving certain Amish and Mennonite religious orders the right to opt out of Social Security, Medicaid and a host of other government benefits.
“The basic religious reason driving their resistance is that, as a religious faith, the church community should take care of its own members,” said Kraybill. “If there’s a disaster like a tornado, fire or hospital bill, the community should come together for that.”
The Obamacare exemption is an extension of the Social Security exemption.
“We don’t want government paying for our things,” said an Amish man from Kinzers, Pennsylvania. “We want to pay our own way.”
The man from Kinzers said his community relies on two funds. Nearly every family contributes monthly to a hospital aid fund, while large bills are also paid with free-will offerings.
Some Amish carry benefit cards, which identify them as members of a community but do not bear names or photographs, to help hospitals keep track of those discounts.
“It simply says they’re a participant,” said Eric Buck, president of Preferred Health Care, which manages the Old Order Group coverage plan for Lancaster County Amish.
One factor that helps keep medical bills down is that farm work and other manual labor keep Amish active for most of their lives, making them less susceptible to chronic conditions like diabetes and heart disease that plague the often-sedentary U.S. population, said Bergen, the hospital executive.
Amish children are more susceptible to recessive genetic disorders, the result of a small and largely insular population.
For the heaviest bills, Amish communities often turn to benefit auctions, nicknamed “mud sales” because of the conditions of the fields where they are held.
On a recent Saturday auction in Gordonville, Pennsylvania, located 10 miles east of Lancaster, young Amish men bid used buggies up to more than $4,000, while hand-made quilts sold for several hundred dollars each.
Most mud sales and benefit auctions benefit specific institutions. The one in Gordonville helped pay bills for the volunteer ambulance company. But a series of five held across the state each year help fund the Clinic for Special Children, a world-class pediatric genetics clinic.
Many Amish at the auction said they had relied on hospital aid to pay their medical bills.
“It’s not stressful,” said an Amish man at the auction. “It’s there when you need it.”
Get ACTIVE Make a difference
PLEASE SHARE- RePost to Reddit, Digg, Facebook, Twitter, etc. (below)
Wall Street Still Sucking Life Out of America Like Vampires at a Blood Drive
13 Mindblowing Facts About America’s Tax-Dodging Corporations
Bank of America: Too Crooked to Fail
Bank Of America Sold $850M In “Toxic Waste” Mortgage Securities: DoJ
Prescription Drugs Now Kill More People In The US Than Heroin And Cocaine Combined
The Pharmaceutical Industry Pt. 1
8 Healthy Drinks that Are Actually Terrible for You
Can You Tell Who’s the Soda Addict and Who’s the Meth Addict?
Modern wheat is a “perfect, chronic poison,”
Farm Bill, Military Vets and Farmers
U.S. High Court Rules for BIG Business
One corrupt party or the other
Make the Rich Even Richer Pt. 4 The System is RIGGED
The SYSTEM is NOT broke, its RIGGED Pt. 3 Can You Trust the President, Congress or the Courts to Protect You
The SYSTEM is NOT broke Pt 2 Everything Is Rigged: The Biggest Price-Fixing Scandal Ever
The SYSTEM is NOT broke, its RIGGED Pt I
10 Most Profitable U.S. Corporations Paid Average Tax Rate Of Just 9 Percent Last Year: Report
These are the facts your government does NOT want you to see
FACT: PROFITABLE Giant multinational corporations Pay ZERO Taxes
How They Stole Your Pay/Job
More Bank BAILOUTS (How the MAFIA looted your bank) Pt.2
More BANK BAILOUTS: How the Mafia looted your bank Pt 1
Stock Market Bubble
An Overview of the United States National Debt
China’s Credit Bubble
Fight against corruption
Civil disobedience rising across America as citizens fed up with criminal government
Protest marks first civil disobedience by Sierra Club
Protestors arrested at Wells Fargo
Photographer Arrested After Taking Photos of Kansas Feedlot
Are you willing to be arrested?
Extreme Civil Disobedience 2013
General Strike In USA
Lessons From Thoreau: Reflection, Integrity, Civil Disobedience
Civil Disobedience by David Byrne
Shut It Down…They Won’t Listen Any Other Way
Constitution Day: Celebrate it by Learning to Enforce It (The first thing you need to do is resist. Noncompliance with the law, here’s how…)
Bankrupting the FED
8 Reasons Young Americans Don’t Fight Back: How the US Crushed Youth Resistance
Reddit Discusses: What’s the Most Evil Corporation in the World?
Money Laundering: Follow the Hedge Funds
Banks Financing Mexican Drug Cartels Admits Wells Fargo
HSBC banks actively laundered money for drug lords and terrorist
Senate investigation: HSBC Banks criminal account holders
C.I.A.s Real Role in the Afghan Heroin Trade
C.I.A & the MAFIA & the Global Drug Trade (Then & Now)
CIA finally admits it was behind 1953 Iran coup
Special Forces Unconventional Warfare Manual 2010
US Central Intelligence Agency trains, arms anti-Syria death squads
US deficit tops $1 trillion for fourth year
Median Household Income in the United States
The 50 Richest Members of Congress
Wealth Gap Between Congress and Average Americans Widens
237 Millionaires in Congress
Traitors (How Congress Profits from Never ending War)
How Google and Facebook Cooperated with the NSA and PRISM
U.S. intelligence mining data from nine U.S. Internet companies in broad secret program
Verizon is turning your phone records over to the government
Obama Defends Right to Take All Your Phone Records
FBI says the Government Is Spying on Americans with Drones, Too
Don’t ask your government for your Privacy, take it back:
An everyman’s guide for going invisible on the internet
Who’s a TERRORIST? Pentagon Says: You Are
6 Brave Govt. Whistleblowers Charged Under the Espionage Act by Obama’s Administration
Know Your Rights: Whistleblower
IRS scandal: Right-wing fear of government isn’t paranoid
We Are The Enemy: Whistleblowers, Journalists, Dissenters, and the People
F.B.I. Counterterrorism Agents Monitored Occupy Movement, Records Show
Pennsylvania Judge Sentenced For 28 Years For Selling Kids to the Prison System
Uncompromising Photos Expose Juvenile Detention in America
Suit claims abuse, filth at juvenile detention center
The Crisis of Juvenile Prison Rape: A New Report: “Sexual abuse in juvenile detention is a national crisis”
Feds: Mississippi county runs ‘school-to-prison pipeline’
Amnesty International Denounces Torture in California Prisons
Law Enforcement Misconduct Statistics
Top 1,000 Cases of police brutality in the United States
Know Your Rights With Police Officers
Know Your Rights- Detention And Pat Down- Do’s and Don’ts
Know Your Rights: Supreme Court Ruling Allows Strip Searches for Any Arrest
The Supreme Court Decided Your Silence Can Be Used Against You
Right of Defense Against Unlawful Arrest
Know Your Rights: False arrest
How do I report police misconduct?
(How to) Detecting Police Personnel/Vehicles
Know Your Rights With Police Officers
Top Ten Reasons Why You Should Not Talk to the Police
10 Ways to Spot an Informant
The most embarrassing graph in American drug policy
DRUG BUST: Five Tips for Spotting an Undercover Cop
How to File a Complaint Against a Police Officer